The New York Times Top 100 Television Shows List(s)

I am not the person to ask about any kind of ranked list. For just about anything, really. This is, in part, because I keep discovering that my opinions about books, movies and television shows changes and that it feels absurd to try and be absolute about these things.

THAT BEING SAID – I’d like to share a few random thoughts about the two lists The New York Times shared regarding the top 100 shows of the twenty-first century.

To begin there are two lists. The first is made by “More than 500 influential stars, showrunners and other notable names in the world of TV voted on the best series released since Jan. 1, 2000.”

So we have people who make television voting what they think the best shows are. Great. I get that. The second list is comprised of “More than 100,000 people.”

So here’s where I get a little cranky. I’m not a math person. At all. But if I were I would point out that asking 500 people to come up with a list and over 100,000 people you would be giving greater weight to the group of 500 people and their votes.

Does this matter all that much? I suppose not only it means whoever these 500 people are they are really shaping what makes the list (and what doesn’t). Something else that stood out to me, when I looked closely at the lists, is that you have the entire gamut of television programming. Dramas, comedies, reality programming and everything in-between is included.

Which perhaps I’m being nit-picky about but it feels wrong. In the same way that the Academy Awards feels wrong each year when they have a category for Best Picture or Best Actor and then have all of the films or actors competing against one another.

How do you measure Survivor against VEEP? These are two very different shows with different purposes (beyond entertainment I suppose) trying to achieve them in different ways. How do you rank them against one another?

Like I said at the beginning I’m not sure there’s any point to this post, it’s just me rambling about things I struggle to get my head around. A limited series is a very different thing than a network television show with twenty-four episodes per season that figures commercial breaks into its structure. Is it fair to compare them? Is there any point in comparing them?

At the end of the day part of the reason why I felt the need to share anything about these lists is due to omissions or (what I perceive as) slights. The most glaring omission being Orphan Black. The show does not appear on either list. That is has, quite easily, the most impressive performances from any actress (ever) and (spoiler here) she does it in multiple roles – that alone should have this show on the list.

Never mind the fact that everyone in Orphan Black is great. That the story is interesting and well told and it is every bit as good as the number one show on both lists (Breaking Bad and I have issues).

Another surprising omission is Firefly. The industry list does not have it and the reader’s list put it at 108 (they put Orphan Black at 163).

Look, we don’t all have to agree and clearly my methodology would differ from the one’s used on either of these. As would my sample size. But one thing I think we can agree on is creating a ranked list and comparing these shows is, for many of us, the thief of joy.

I watched Widow’s Bay this summer and loved it. It was not what I expected and despite the hype I was sucked in to this wonderful, beautifully made show. So far it has one season. Do I want to compare it to something like Firefly (or any other great one season show)? I do not. There’s no need to. I can love both (or all).

It does stick in my craw that wonderful, interesting shows like The OA and Community rank so low on the industry list when other things rank so highly. It shouldn’t bother me but I feel outside influences are affecting these ratings. That you have near constant buzz online about certain shows (or movies or bands) is the reason they have such high spots (not because everyone watches and loves them). Then making lists such as these increases the online noise, which gives these shows more attention and the cycle continues.

Again the issue truly being the rankings. If these were unranked and it was simply a list I don’t think I would bother to write anything. I agree with most of the shows on the lists. There are many I have not watched and do not plan on watching that I understand the inclusion of. The ranking is truly what irritates and annoys me.

There’s no clever ending to this post and I apologize if you read this and feel it was a waste of your time. With television and films it increasingly feels to me that so much that is written and said is just noise. Whether it is a ranked list, or box office earnings or awards given. These are just metrics to measure success.

Which if you are a person making these shows and movies I can see the value of. Despite the fact that continually we have works of art that these metrics deem failures which, we all agree on, are not. For the rest of us I fail to see any great meaning in these metrics. Instead, what I used to value greatly, were the personal recommendations and conversations I would have with people I know and respect.

If Jolene from work says One Tree Hill is the greatest television show ever made I would take it with a grain of salt. If my movie buddy Tommy tells me I need to get over myself and give One Battle After Another a second chance that carries a great deal of weight.

Which, I suppose, is what I attempt to do here when I post about specific films and shows despite not knowing any of you who read my posts. How effective this is, how useful this is I do not now. Please believe me when I say I do put thought and effort into these recommendations and I don’t simply regurgitate what I read about show number sixteen from a list like this.

At the end of the day I’m not trying to take away from anyone’s enjoyment or diminish the praise and admiration for any of these shows (I only mentioned Breaking Bad and that’s because of a number of issues with the show no one ever seems to address – I still watched it and think it’s a great show). Lists like this always make me feel that is part of their intention – by diminishing one show it raises another up. And I don’t care for that.

Leave a Reply